Poll Description - Rhea, clearly mid-party (Is thrilled to suddenly grow bigger and more muscular)
Though it was later confirmed that the punch was enchanted and responsible for Rhea's sudden growth, it turned out there was but a minuscule chance of it happening, and only women could get such a result.
It is true that every man at the party who eagerly grabbed a cup did transform a short while after, but all of them became lean and androgynous with fantastic hair instead of huge and beefy.
Though many were disappointed by their newly acquired beauty, one normally heavyset party-goer who wished to LARP as an elf the following day was delighted.