This really does beg certain questions. I mean, yes. Weird stuff happens at Tedd’s house, but spoiler warning, making GOO come to life would still be pretty freakin’ weird!
I guess there could have been weird incidents that haven’t made it into the comic yet. Maybe Tedd brought some pudding to life once by mistake? I’m pretty sure he didn’t, but maybe I could claim he did so Elliot’s nonchalantness makes perfect sense? I’m sure no one would question it.
So, yeah. Tedd made pudding come to life once. Fortunately, he was armed with a spoon, so he was able to make short work of it.
Commentary added August 8th, 2014